Expert Series: Turning Doubtful Executives into Coaching Advocates Part 1
I created and led the executive coaching practice at a Fortune 100 health insurance company. While executives showed an interest in coaching for senior leaders, they were skeptical about coaching as a profession and as a method of accelerating development. When you lead a coaching practice inside a company that’s full of actuaries, finance executives, risk analysist, physicians, and clinicians who are skeptical of coaching. They referred to coaching as “ a bit too woo-woo for me,” or “something that happens in a secret black box, so it’s too mysterious for business.”
About that time, more neuroscience research and brain-based coaching approaches began to emerge. I knew that coaching inside this company would thrive, but only if it were based on science, process, and an approach that executives could understand and trust. Since then, I started my own executive coaching practice and continue to bring brain-based coaching solutions to my clients.
In this series, I’ll share how doubtful executives approach and embrace the neuroscience of coaching to become coaching advocates. In this edition, I’ll share my experience with a skeptical chief operating officer.
It’s Not Neuroscience, It’s Pixie Dust!
The ultimate test of implementing a brain-based coaching practice at my company came when the chief operating officer called me to his office one day. I wasn’t sure what he wanted to discuss, and I was concerned that he wanted to end the coaching practice at the company. I thought it would be my last day at the company.
We sat down, and he said, “You’ve been coaching some people on my team, and here’s what it looks like to me. You start meeting them, you take off the top of their skull, and you sprinkle pixie dust on their brain. (Yes, the COO actually used the words ‘pixie dust’.) He continued, “Then you put the top of their skull back on, and after six months of coaching, they’re doing all these things that I’ve been wanting them to do for years. They’re getting success in the business and interacting with me and the team in ways that I really wanted.” I said, ‘Well if you’re not the person I’m coaching, it can appear as if pixie dust is working some kind of magic. Actually, it’s the neuroscience of coaching that’s working.” I discussed some brain-based coaching applications and reflective questions I use. At the end of our conversation, he said, “I just want you to know that I get it, that there’s science behind coaching, and that it’s making a difference.”
When I left his office, I breathed a heavy sigh of relief that the coaching practice wasn’t ending. And I realized that brain-based coaching soothes that queasy feeling that some executives get when they think coaching is too mysterious for business or too “woo-woo” to be effective. Start a conversation about the science of coaching with your clients, company executives, human resource professionals, and other influencers in the organization. It’s not rocket science; it’s brain science that wins over corporate skeptics.
Watch for our next part in 2 weeks.
Jeff Nally, PCC is an executive coach, coaching supervisor, professional speaker. and author. He is the president of Nally Group Inc., a practice focused on the science of leadership and human interaction. Jeff is vice president of marketing for the ICF Ohio Valley Chapter, is a member and volunteer with the Gay Coaches Alliance, and is the co-author of two anthologies: Humans@Work and Rethinking HR. He can be reached at Email me! and or check out my website.
The Expert Series is brought to you by choice Magazine as part of our ongoing efforts to bring opportunities for learning and growth to the coaching community. Delivered in four parts every two weeks, each series covers useful topics for business development and coaching insights, serving the needs of leaders in all areas and walks of life. Archived copies of the previous series can be found here.